The battle between heirloom and hybrid varieties is longstanding. There are positives and negatives to either and tomato aficionados will fight to the end to defend their favorites. Heirloom varieties have been past down from generation to generation, where as, hybrids have been bred to take the best qualities from each parent plant. It is said that hybrids tend to have better disease resistance and higher yields, while heirloom varieties tend to have better colors and taste.
As shared in our previous post Harvest Time Recipes , we have been growing and selling our own tomatoes here at Romence Gardens. The first batch of plants is now done and we have started a fresh crop that includes peppers and basil. In the first batch we grew 10 different varieties, some heirloom and some hybrid so that we could really see which type is supreme. Here’s what we found:
The hybrid varieties that we grew included Fresh Salsa, Better Boy, Early Girl, Jet Star, Husky Cherry Red, and Napa Grape. These as a group produced more tomatoes compared to the heirloom varieties and had less cracking and disease problems. The Fresh Salsa was the clear winner when it came to amount of tomatoes produced. It is a determinate variety, meaning it produces the majority of its fruit at one time (to see more info on determinate vs indeterminate check out one of our previous posts Tomato Talk). During our staff taste test Better Boy was the hybrid favorite with Napa Grape following behind.
The heirlooms we grew were Cherokee Purple, Yellow Pear, Mortgage Lifter, and Kellogg’s Breakfast. Cherokee Purple and Yellow Pear were our top performers in terms of amount of fruit produced. Mortgage Lifter produced the least amount of tomatoes out of all of the varieties combined. Where the heirlooms seemed to lack in abundance they gained back during the taste test. The overall staff favorite was Cherokee Purple, with Kellogg’s Breakfast a very close second. People also liked Mortgage Lifter’s meaty flavor. These heirloom varieties also tended to be less acidic then the hybrid varieties we tasted.
The top 5 Romence Staff Picks are as follows:
1) Cherokee Purple
2) Kellogg’s Breakfast
3) Better Boy
4) Napa Grape
5) Mortgage Lifter
Overall it was a fun experiment and made us realize the benefits to both types of tomatoes. It is hard to pick a definitive winner, so we’ll let you form your own opinions on that!
With the tomato season coming to an end in your gardens be sure to come check out our stock of homegrown veggies; they’ll be ready in the next couple of weeks!









THYME
‘Timely’ Plant list


















